| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Full paper |
1 Service de Radiologie A
2 Pédiatrie, Hôpital Pellegrin, Place A Raba Léon, 33076 Bordeaux, Cedex, France
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Material and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Imaging data were analysed in another group of 13 children with no stigmata of NF-1 on physical examination and no family history of NF-1 but who were evaluated during the same period with imaging for an optic pathway tumour.
Imaging studies
T1 weighted, proton density and T2 weighted MR images were obtained in all patients. Axial, coronal and sagittal images were studied. T1 weighted images were repeated after intravenous infusion of DTPA- or DOTA-gadolinium (0.1 mmol kg-1). Fat saturated contrast enhanced T1 weighted images were used in a few patients. The examination was conducted after sedation in children under the age of 4 years.
Imaging diagnostic criteria of an optic pathway lesion were a size or signal abnormality, or both, along the optic pathways. In cases with subtle changes in size, an abnormality was considered to be present when there was asymmetry between the two sides. The site of origin of the tumour may be difficult to determine in large suprasellar masses: the chiasma was considered to be primarily involved when it was not visible as a normal structure at the anterior margin of the tumour on sagittal and axial images.
The images were evaluated independently by two radiologists. Results were achieved by consensus when they did not fully agree. The following data were recorded: (i) location of the tumour at the time of initial diagnosis: lesion of the optic nerve (single or bilateral), in its intraorbital portion or its intracranial portion, lesion of the chiasma alone, or with forward extension into the optic nerves, involvement of thechiasma and the retrochiasmal optic pathways; (ii) maximum diameter of the tumour on axial slices; (iii) structure of the mass, especially whether or not there was a cystic component; (iv)presence and type of enhancement after gadolinium infusion; and (v) presence of other abnormalities: ventricular dilatation, abnormal parenchymal hyperintense signal on T2 weighted images, or other tumours.
Follow-up imaging studies were obtained for every child and the same parameters were assessed. The mean time of follow-up for the children with NF-1 was 3.5 years. Increases in tumour volume, modifications in enhancement and spreading of lesions along the optical tract were also studied at follow-up.
Data analysis
To determine whether there were significant differences between patients with NF-1 vs those without NF-1, continuous variables were analysed using Student's t-test, and frequency data were compared using
2 analyses.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Initial symptoms
Clinical signs are summarized in Table 1
. These signs at the time of diagnosis are not comparable between the two groups, because in the group with NF-1 most children were explored because of this initial disease: 11 of the subjects with NF-1 did not have specific neurological symptoms and were identified by neuroimaging study at the time of diagnosis of NF-1. The other three presented with symptoms (see Table 1
). Ophthalmological examination showed Lisch nodules in only one child. Family history of NF-1 was found in five cases. Two of the children in the NF-1 group had facial features of Noonan syndrome, including hypertelorism, proptosis, micrognathia and ear abnormalities. Visual evoked potentials were abnormal in all cases, with prolonged latencies.
|
Imaging
Imaging results are presented in Table 2
(tumour localization) and Table 3
(other characteristics).
|
|
|
The tumour was enhanced by gadolinium in 4 of the 14 children. In two cases at diagnosis, enhancement was moderate and heterogeneous (Figure 2
), and in the other two it was intense and homogeneous.
|
Non-NF-1 group
The chiasma was regularly involved (11 cases). One child presented with a lesion involving the entire right optic nerve with extension into the chiasma. Another child had involvement of the chiasma and of the retrochiasmal optic pathways. In the longest axis, the minimum tumour size was 16 mm and the maximum was 80 mm (average 42.4 mm). In this group, the tumour was typically nodular in form, well defined and contained both solid and cystic components (Figure 3
). A cystic component was found in 7 of the 13 children at diagnosis. No intratumoral calcification or surrounding oedema was noted. Tumour enhancement was intense and homogeneous in the solid portions of the tumour in 10 of these 13 children.
|
Comparison of NF-1 and non-NF-1 groups
There were two characteristics regarding tumour location. In the NF-1 group, the optic nerves were involved more frequently than the chiasma or retrochiasmal pathways, with unilateral optic nerve involvement being most characteristic. In the non-NF-1 group, the tumour was most often located in the chiasma and no isolated optic nerve involvement was noted. There was a statistically significant difference in size between the two groups (p=0.01). Tumours occurring in patients who did not have NF-1 were approximately twice as long as tumours in NF-1 patients. Contrast enhancement and a cystic component were more frequent in the non-NF-1 group.
Treatment and outcome
In the NF-1 group, the optic pathway tumour was treated in two of the children by radiation therapy and in a third by chemotherapy. Only one biopsy was obtained, demonstrating a grade I astrocytoma. No therapy was initially given for the 11 remaining children. They were monitored by clinical examination and MRI once every 6 or 12 months. Changes were seen in five children. In one child, enhancement was first noted during a follow-up examination at 4 years; at that time, a hyperintense signal on T2 weighted images had developed in the optic tract, even though the volume of the tumour in the chiasma remained unchanged. In three cases, the tumour increased in volume (Figure 4
) and hyperintensity developed on T2 weighted images. In a fifth patient, clinical signs of raised intracranial pressure permitted the diagnosis of a second tumour in the optic pathways (Figure 5
). In this last case, imaging aspects were similar to those observed in the non-NF-1 group, with enhancement by contrast medium. Three deaths occurred in this group, in one case owing to rapid progression of the optic pathway tumour (Figure 5
). The second death was caused by a thoracoabdominal neurofibrosarcoma and the third by a grade III astrocytoma of the frontal lobe.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
These tumours occur in young children, generally before the age of 5 years. As in other comparative studies [25], there was no difference in the mean age of discovery between the two groups. Listernick et al [6, 7] did not find any children older than 6 years, without anomaly of the optic pathways, who developed a symptomatic tumour or in whom tumour growth was rapid. This suggests that efforts to detect such tumours in this location in children with NF-1 should be made before the age of 6 years.
It is not possible to compare the initial clinical signs in our two groups, because the circumstances of imaging are not the same. All children without NF-1 in the present study had clinical symptoms in relation to the tumour. 10 (71%) of the children among the 14 who had NF-1 were asymptomatic, in agreement with the 6075% ofasymptomatic patients reported in other series [5, 6, 8]. This could be related to the location and size of these tumours. The commonest clinical manifestation of these tumours is decreased visual acuity. Intracranial hypertension and nystagmus are encountered with expansive chiasmatic tumours [3]. Precocious puberty in patients with NF-1 is a rare but evocative finding in optic chiasma tumours, resulting in hypothalamic dysfunction [4, 9]. In our study, we observed one case of precocious puberty in a child with a tumour of the optic chiasma. According to Listernick et al [7], precocious puberty never occurs in a child with NF-1 in the absence of a a tumour of the optic chiasma, but in another series glioma of the optic pathway was not encountered in all cases [10]. Consequently, children who have NF-1 should always be carefully examined for clinical signs of precocious puberty [11]. Although no increase in the incidence of optic glioma has previously been described when there is an association of NF-1 and Noonan syndrome, we observed two such cases.
Visual evoked potentials were abnormal in all cases within the present series who underwent this examination. This is a sensitive but non-specific test for the presence of an optic tumour. Visual evoked potentials may be of value in the decision regarding treatment and follow-up of young or asymptomatic children [12].
As in other studies [2, 7], we observed a statistically significant difference between the two groups regarding the location of these tumours. The lesion involved the optic nerves in most of the NF-1 group. Bilateral optic nerve tumours, regardless of the portion of the optic nerve involved, are a specific neuroradiological sign of NF-1 [7, 13, 14]. In the absence of NF-1, tumours were predominantly located in the chiasma. None of the children without NF-1 had an isolated optic nerve lesion. This difference in location may partly explain the difference in clinical patterns, and perhaps the difference in prognosis [15].
The morphology and structure of these tumours also differ depending on whether or not there is associated NF-1. In children with NF-1, the lesion of the optic nerves corresponds either to a tubular and tortuous widening of the nerve, or to a spindle-shaped mass. In patients who have NF-1, Stern et al [15] emphasized the particular anatomopathological architecture of these tumours, which consists of circumferential perineural infiltration extending into subarachnoid spaces and generally preserving the central optic nerve. This tumour morphology is visible on T1 weighted images, giving the nerve a spindle shape that is isointense to the cerebral parenchyma. T2 weighted sequences show a hyperintense signal corresponding to the gliomatosis, which surrounds hypointense nerve fibres [14, 16, 17]. Fat saturated contrast enhanced T1 weighted images can be useful in depicting the extent of the lesion [18]. Proliferation involves an elongation of the nerve, which develops a tortuous appearance. The fact that the lesion develops perineurally, without involvement of the neurons at the initial stage, may explain the limited effect on visual function. In the chiasma, these tumours are typically small and homogeneous, have no cystic component, and are variably enhanced by contrast media. In three of the present children with NF-1, a chiasmal lesion extended into the optic nerves, and in two others it extended into the posterior optic tract. These features suggest a tumoral process that infiltrates the entire optic tract.
In patients who do not have NF-1, tumours of the optic pathways have the same imaging features as pilocytic astrocytomas at other sites [19]. They are generally round, well delineated masses with a cystic component and a solid portion. They are intensely and homogeneously enhanced by contrast media. Histopathological examination shows intraneural growth of the tumour in most cases [15].
Other imaging anomalies were observed in children with NF-1. In 12 (86%), we noted focal hyperintensities on T2 weighted sequences. This incidence is higher than that found overall in NF-1 (5070%) [2022]. This increased frequency of these lesions in children who have both NF-1 and a tumour of the optic pathways has been found by others [20, 22, 23] and the question of a possible relationship between these hyperintense signals and the natural history of these tumours remains. We also noted the presence of other cerebral tumours in 3 of the 14 children with NF-1. This association between gliomas of the optic pathways and other tumours of the central nervous system has also been reported [23, 24], in particular in children younger than 10 years of age [8].
We studied the natural course of these tumours only in the NF-1 group, because all the children who did not have NF-1 were treated. MRI demonstrated changes of the optic pathway tumour in only five of our children with NF-1, with a progression in size in four children. This was found by Listernick et al [3] in the same proportion of patients. Clinical signs were associated with progression of the tumour in only one child, who died owing to this progression. In this case, imaging findings were the same as in the non-NF-1 group. The majority of these lesions are stable. However, as stressed in many publications, the course may range from spontaneous regression [5, 2528] to aggressive development [2931]. The period of follow-up in our study does not permit long-term assessment of survival [4]. The overall survival rate can be rather worse in NF-1, because children with NF-1 develop other tumours [2, 4, 32]. In our series, two children had another tumour, evolution of which was fatal.
The course of the optic lesions is often unpredictable [31]. We found no predictive MRI criterion of progression of these tumours in children with NF-1. Initial localization, enhancement and structure of the tumour were not correlated with course. Histologically, pilocytic astrocytomas appear to be a very mixed group of tumours. There are no macroscopic or microscopic histopathological criteria that predict the course. Assessment of proliferative activity with the MIB-1 labelling index (expression of proliferative cell nuclear antigen) does not assist in clinical decision-making, although the MIB-1 increased to 15.2% and 18% in two patients with NF-1 who developed highly malignant gliomas 6 years and 6.5 years after irradiation [33]. Flow cytometry analysis also fails to indicate subsequent tumour development [34]. After treatment, one study has shown that, in NF-1, relapse-free survival improves with increasing age, and with chemotherapy and radiotherapy [35]. Better comprehension of the genetic modifications present in these tumours, such as inactivation of the p53 gene and amplification of epidermal growth factor, may provide other clues [36].
Screening for tumours of the optic pathways in asymptomatic children who harbour NF-1 remains a subject of debate. The consensus view does not recommend the routine use of MRI in a child on whom the diagnosis of NF-1 has just been made [1], as MRI does not modify the follow-up or treatment of NF-1 [6, 7]. Nevertheless, brain MRI can provide additional arguments in favour of the diagnosis of NF-1. Some advocate the presence of specific MRI anomalies, such as focal T2 hyperintensities or widening of the space between the optic nerves, among diagnostic criteria [21, 22, 37]. Once the diagnosis has been made, this examination can be used as a reference. If the child develops clinical signs, this will permit one to judge any progression of the tumour [24]. This should not, however, overshadow the importance of clinical examination, which remains fundamental in the follow-up, supplemented by screening with visual evoked potentials [12].
The present study suggests that optic gliomas that develop in children with NF-1 differ from the optic pathway lesions found in children who do not have NF-1. In NF-1, optic pathway tumours occur predominantly anterior to the chiasma, and may correspond to perineural gliomatosis rather than true pilocytic astrocytomas. They have only a slight tendency to progress but chiasma location can occur, sometimes with a different course. In asymptomatic children with NF-1 in our study, initial imaging provided no predictive criteria of tumour progression.
Received for publication May 25, 2000. Revision received August 29, 2000. Accepted for publication September 25, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. K. Sharma, D. B. Mansur, G. Reifenberger, A. Perry, J. R. Leonard, K. D. Aldape, M. G. Albin, R. J. Emnett, S. Loeser, M. A. Watson, et al. Distinct Genetic Signatures among Pilocytic Astrocytomas Relate to Their Brain Region Origin Cancer Res., February 1, 2007; 67(3): 890 - 900. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Czyzyk, S. Jozwiak, M. Roszkowski, and R. A. Schwartz Optic Pathway Gliomas in Children With and Without Neurofibromatosis 1 J Child Neurol, July 1, 2003; 18(7): 471 - 478. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| BJR | DMFR | IMAGING | ALL BIR JOURNALS |